Why Does Amazon Have So Few Western Rivals in Online Shopping?

From everyday household essentials to entertainment, groceries, cloud computing and digital devices, Amazon has become deeply integrated into modern life. Its enormous range of interconnected services has helped it build one of the most powerful business ecosystems in the world.

Originally launched by Jeff Bezos in 1995 as an online bookstore, Amazon has grown into a global technology and retail giant. Earlier in 2026, it overtook Walmart to become the world’s largest company by annual sales, according to NPR’s report.

But despite the presence of major retailers and online marketplaces, why has no Western competitor managed to seriously challenge Amazon’s dominance in eCommerce?

Amazon’s competitors are struggling to close the gap

Amazon does face competition from established retailers and specialist online platforms. Walmart and Target continue expanding their online businesses in the United States, while Tesco leads the UK’s online grocery market. Germany’s Zalando is a major online fashion retailer, and Chinese platforms such as Temu and Shein are competing aggressively on low prices.

eBay also remains an important marketplace, particularly for second-hand goods, collectibles and auctions. It recently rejected a $55.5 billion takeover proposal from GameStop, following the original announcement of the offer.

However, Amazon’s overall market position remains significantly stronger.

According to figures reported by Statista, Amazon accounted for approximately 40.5% of US online retail sales, compared with 9.2% for Walmart and around 3% for eBay. In the UK, Amazon’s share is estimated at approximately 30%, according to Texintel.

First-mover advantage and a long-term growth strategy

One of Amazon’s biggest advantages was entering online retail early and recognising the potential of internet shopping before many traditional retailers.

Its strategy was not simply to generate immediate profits. For years, Amazon prioritised expansion, competitive pricing and reinvestment, allowing it to build infrastructure, attract customers and establish market share.

This long-term approach was difficult for traditional retailers to replicate, particularly those under pressure to deliver short-term returns to shareholders.

Amazon also benefits from its highly profitable businesses, especially Amazon Web Services (AWS). Revenue from cloud computing and other business divisions provides financial strength to support investment across its wider retail ecosystem.

The power of Amazon’s marketplace and Prime membership

Two major developments helped transform Amazon’s competitive position.

The first was its move towards becoming a marketplace where independent businesses could sell products alongside Amazon’s own retail operations. More sellers brought a wider product selection, attracting more customers. More customers, in turn, encouraged additional sellers to join.

This created a powerful network effect that is difficult for new competitors to reproduce.

The second was Amazon Prime, introduced in the United States in 2005 and the UK in 2007. Its subscription model offered convenient delivery benefits and gradually expanded to include films, television programmes and other services.

As the membership package grew, customers had more reasons to remain within Amazon’s ecosystem.

Amazon therefore competes through more than product prices. Its combination of convenience, delivery, marketplace choice, entertainment and technology makes it particularly difficult for competitors to match.

Emily West, who has researched Amazon’s business model, explores these issues in her book Buy Now.

Competition concerns and legal challenges

Amazon’s dominance has also attracted scrutiny from competition regulators.

The US Federal Trade Commission and the state of California have brought separate antitrust cases alleging that Amazon uses practices that restrict competition and protect its market position.

A central allegation in the FTC’s case concerns how third-party sellers are treated when they offer lower prices on competing websites. The regulator alleges that sellers may face disadvantages in Amazon’s marketplace, including reduced visibility or losing access to prominent purchasing features.

California has also made evidence from its investigation publicly accessible.

Amazon denies the allegations and is defending the legal proceedings. The US cases are expected to face further developments, including trials scheduled for 2027.

Some campaigners have called for Amazon to be divided into separate businesses to encourage greater competition. Others believe such a move is unlikely, particularly given the complexity of the company’s operations and the outcomes of other major technology competition cases, including Google’s recent case.

Could artificial intelligence become Amazon’s next major competitor?

Interestingly, Amazon’s next serious competitive challenge may not come from another traditional retailer.

Generative AI is beginning to change how consumers discover products, compare prices and make purchasing decisions. Shopping experiences integrated directly into AI platforms could allow customers to research and purchase products without visiting conventional retail websites.

This could create new opportunities for businesses that want to compete with established online marketplaces.

If AI-powered shopping platforms become widely adopted, the relationship between consumers, retailers and digital marketplaces could change significantly.

The bigger picture

Amazon’s success is built on decades of investment, a powerful marketplace, customer loyalty, technology infrastructure and an interconnected portfolio of businesses.

Although competing with Amazon remains difficult, its dominance does not necessarily make the market impossible to challenge.

The next generation of eCommerce competition may come from a different direction altogether: AI-powered shopping, personalised product discovery and new digital marketplaces that change how people buy online.

Original source (Credit):
BBC News – Why does Amazon have no Western rivals?
This article is an independently prepared, AI-assisted summary of reporting originally published by BBC News. The original source is credited above. The content has been condensed and rewritten for informational purposes.

Leave A Comment